Jesus’ parable of the workers in the vineyard shows us God, that in His infinite generosity bestows the same blessing on those workers that arrived late as on those that labored all day. This while not diminishing the great blessings on the full day laborers. If looked at from the perspective of eternity the present is the only thing that matters. We only live in the present. The love that we show at the present moment is the measure of our life at each moment. While God, love and eternity transcend time, here on earth it is hard not to live on a timeline with past, present and future driving our thoughts. This is very evident in the NFL where players strive to excel within a window of opportunity and feel the dreaded “past their prime” words so early in their lives. The statistics show that the ability to excel early is a strong indication of being on the path for a Hall of Fame Gold jacket. Lets look at what these statistics tell us and the players that are on this early path to NFL success.
To measure success I will use the Approximate Value (AV) metric developed by Pro Football Reference to measure a player’s value across seasons and positions.
1. Hypotheses
Null Hypothesis (H0): There is no difference in the Hall of Fame induction rate between NFL players who achieve an AV of 11 or better by age 22 and those who achieve it later. (The probability of induction is the same for both groups).
Alternative Hypothesis (H1): NFL players who achieve an AV of 11 or better by age 22 have a significantly higher rate of Hall of Fame induction than those who achieve it later.
2. Proposed Sample Groups
To get a valid p-value, we need to compare two distinct samples of retired, HOF-eligible players (typically those retired for at least 5 years).
Test Group (Group A): All players in NFL history who recorded a single-season AV of 11 or higher during or before their age-22 season. The query is Number of seasons player meets criteria from 1960 to 2020, age 22 or younger, is not active, in the regular season, requiring Approximate Value >= 11. Then From 1960 to 2020, age 22 or younger, is not active, a member of the Hall of Fame, in the regular season, requiring Approximate Value >= 11.
Control Group (Group B): All other players in NFL history who reached the 11 AV threshold at age 23 or older. Number of seasons player meets criteria, from 1960 to 2020, age 23 or older, is not active, in the regular season, requiring Approximate Value >= 11. Then those that made the Hall of Fame.
3. Methodology for P-Value
We would likely use a Fisher’s Exact Test or a Chi-Square Test of Independence to compare the proportions of HOFers in each group.
Data Points: For each group, count the number of “Inducted” vs. “Not Inducted.”Significance: If our resulting p-value is < 0.05, we would reject the null hypothesis, suggesting that hitting this specific AV benchmark early is indeed a statistically significant “insinuation” of a Hall of Fame trajectory.
4. The Data
The above queries at Stathead.com yielded
Av 11 by age 22
28 of 103 made Hall of Fame
AV 11 after age 22
176 of 1650 made Hall of Fame
5. Results for Our Data
First, we determine the probability (p) of making the Hall of Fame for each group:
Group 1 (By age 22): p1 = 28/103 = 27.18%
Group 2 (After age 22): p2 = 176/1650 = 10.67%
The players who achieved an AV of 11 by age 22 are more than 2.5 times more likely to make the Hall of Fame than those who did so later.
To ensure this difference isn’t due to random chance, a Fisher’s Exact Test was performed on the data:
Null Hypothesis: There is no difference in Hall of Fame probability between the two groups.
Alternative Hypothesis: Achieving AV 11 by age 22 is associated with a different probability of making the Hall of Fame.
P-Value: 0.00000797
Since the p-value is extremely small, we reject the null hypothesis. The difference is highly statistically significant. The group that achieved an AV of 11 by age 22 is statistically significant, as its 27.18% Hall of Fame induction rate is significantly higher than the 10.67% rate for those reaching the mark later (p < 0.00001).
Calculating a z score we get A Z-score of 5.06 which is extremely high. For a standard significance level of a=0.05, the critical value is approximately 1.96. Since 5.06 > 1.96, the p-value is nearly zero (p < 0.0001). This indicates that the probability of this difference occurring by random chance is negligible.
The difference of being 2.5 times more likely is minor when looked at all NFL players who have a less than 1% chance of making the Hall of Fame. But when you look at say just the first round players whose chance goes up to anywhere from 7 to 15%. Then 2.5 times that is significant.
Since you have suffered through an amatuer statistical analysis, you are entitled to a spreadsheet of active players that have achieved an AV of 8 or better by the age of 22. An AV of 8 is considered a good player. The Main sheet contains all the players. You can filter on things like position, year or first AV. The AV is listed as first occurence of AV greater than or equal to 8 and then following columns is how they did in AV for each succeeding season. The spreadsheet is Active with Young AV. The season column is the season they got the AV of 8 or better by age 22.
So who are some of the potential young draft prospects? Here is a list with birthdates obtained from Wikipedia
Caleb Downs (S, Ohio State): Born December 10, 2004 (age 21)
Rueben Bain Jr. (EDGE, Miami): Born September 8, 2004 (age 21)
Jeremiyah Love (RB, Notre Dame): Born May 31, 2005 (age 20)
Carnell Tate (WR, Ohio State): Born January 19, 2005 (age 21)
Arvell Reese (LB, Ohio State):Born August 30, 2005 (age 20)
Francis Mauigoa (OT, Miami): Born June 4, 2005 (age 20)
Peter Woods (DL, Clemson): Born March 5, 2005 (age 20)
Jermod McCoy (CB, Tennessee): Born August 16, 2005 (age 20)
T.J. Parker (EDGE, Clemson): Born September 19, 2004 (age 21)
Dante Moore (QB, Oregon): Born May 24, 2005 (age 20)
Kadyn Proctor (OT, Alabama): Born June 4, 2005 (age 20)
Malik Muhammad (CB, Texas): Born September 14, 2004 (age 21)
Matayo Uiagalelei (EDGE, Oregon): Born July 2, 2005 (age 20)
Sonny Styles (LB, Ohio State): Born November 24, 2004
CJ Allen (LB, Georgia):Born March 1, 2005
Makai Lemon (WR, USC):Born June 2, 2004 (age 21)
Kamari Ramsey (S, USC): Born August 24, 2004 (age 21)
Zachariah Branch, WR (Georgia): Born March 29, 2004 (age 21)
Keldric Faulk, EDGE (Auburn): Born September 7, 2004 (age 21)
Brandon Cisse (CB, South Carolina) Born July 3, 2005 (age 20)
Gracen Halton (DT, Oaklahoma) Born January 27, 2004 (age 22)
Here was my recent New York Giants mock draft looking for some young talented players of need. Age is as of December 2026.
5
Caleb Downs
S | Ohio State
21 yrs
37
Brandon Cisse
CB | South Carolina
21 yrs
105
Gracen Halton
DL | Oklahoma
22 yrs
143
Beau Stephens
IOL | Iowa
23 yrs
185
Eric McAlister
WR | TCU
23-24 yrs
191
Dallen Bentley
TE | Utah
25 yrs
192
Tyreak Sapp
EDGE | Florida
24 yrs
I hope you enjoy the data. I found it interesting. It is amazing how long some of these young achievers have played. It also highlights how solid good some of them have consistently played. Going back to the opening. Remember we are destined for an eternity of love and are never past the window of opportunity as long as we strive to live the moment with the love of God and others. The quest for a Hall of Fame Gold jacket is only an earthly ‘immortality’ strictly earned by merit. While the NFL may cast aside those ‘past their prime,’ the parable of the vineyard reminds us that God’s economy operates on a different logic. In the spiritual life, the true ‘Gold Jacket’ of eternal life is an unmerited gift of grace, available even to those who arrive at the eleventh hour.
Featured image: Drums600, CC BY-SA 4.0 <https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0>, via Wikimedia Commons
Leave a Reply